Blog Layout

Living in community

Alexandra Weeber • 26 september 2020

More important than a healthy diet?


In one of my favorite books ‘More brain less medicine’, dr. Lissa Rankin describes an amazing discovery that has been done in the 60s in the village Roseto, close to Pennsylvania, about the effect of living in community on physical health. Below I’ll recap what she describes.  


Back in the day, Roseto was inhabited by Italian immigrants who were looking for a brighter future for their children. Their life was not necessarily healthy in the physical sense; they worked long days in the quarries and textile factories. The typical diet composed of mountains of pasta, Italian sausages, meatballs baked in bacon oil, and wine was flowing richly. For lack of money for olive oil, cooking was done in lard. In fact, 41% of their calories came from fat. Many of them smoked and little exercise was done. 

In the 60s, dr. Stewart Wolf, whose attention was drawn by coincidence by Rosetos local doctor, made a remarkable discovery: in a time that heart attacks occurred in epidemic proportions and counted as the most important cause of death in men under age 65, the occurrence of heart attacks in men under age 65 in Roseto had nearly been 0 in the previous 7 years. The amount of heart attacks was about half of the national average, whereas the number of Rosetos neighboring city Bangor did correspond with the national average. Further investigation also pointed out that there was no cases of suicide, alcoholism, or drug addiction, and that there was hardly any crime. No one needed benefits, and ulcers were non-occurring either. People mainly died of old age. 


Extensive research was being done to find an explanation for the apparent immunity for disease in this population and as much as two-thirds of the population was being followed, questioned and examined in many ways. The explanation would obviously not be found in the unhealthy diet and lack of exercise, and genetic factors didn’t seem to play a role either. So they investigated quality of drinking water and of medical care compared to surrounding places, but no explanation was found. Eventually the researchers concluded that it was the way of living that protected Rosetos inhabitants against diseases.


Rankin describes this way of living as follows: “At night you’ll see how the town Roseto will come to life when people return from their jobs, strolling through the main street, halting to gossip with the neighbors and maybe drink a glass of wine with them before going home and get dressed for dinner. When the church bells ring, you’ll see the women gather together in communal kitchens to prepare a classic Italian feast, while the men move the tables together in anticipation of the evening ritual that brings the community together… Multiple generation homes are the norm. Everybody goes to church. Neighbours regularly walk into each others kitchens and the holidays are cheerfully celebrated together. The work ethic in the community is strong. Not only does everybody in Roseto have a job, they share a common mission, a life goal that brings some relief to their grueling work: they dream of a better life for their children. The people of Roseto take care of each other. Nobody in Roseto will be left to their own devices. Roseto in 1961 is the living proof of the power of the clan."


Dr. Stewart Wolf concluded from his research that a strongly connected community that support each other, is a better predictor of a healthy heart than cholesterol levels and tobacco use. 


Later, the importance of community was shown once again, but this time unfortunately by lack thereof.

“While the people of Rosetto exhausted themselves in the quarries and textile factories, sacrificing themselves for a better future for their children, the younger generation wasn’t so happy at all with the life in Rosetto, which in their eyes seemed immune for modernization. When the young people left to study, they brought back new ideas to Roseto, new dreams and new people. Italian Americans started to marry non-Italians, kids didn’t go to church anymore, became part of different associations and moved to single family homes with pools and fences. Because of these changes, multigenerational homes fell into disrepair and social life shifted from communal evening meals to the ‘everyone-for-themselves’ philosophy that was common in neighboring municipalities. The neighbors that previously regularly visited each other unanticipated, would now make an appointment by telephone. The evening ritual of singing adults while the kids played with marbles and played tag, changed into evenings in front of the television.”


The effect of the loss of the once so strongly connected community soon translated into a decline in the physical health of this population. “In 1971, when the amount of heart attacks in other parts of the country decreased because of a widespread adoption of healthier eating habits and regular exercise, for the first time in Roseto someone of the age under 45 died of a heart attack. The next decennium the amount of heart diseases doubled in Roseto. The amount of cases of high blood pressure tripled. The amount of strokes increased. By the end of the 70s, the amount of fatal heart attacks leveled the national average.”


Dr. Wolf concluded that an isolated individual can easily become overwhelmed by the challenges of every day and this can provoke a stress response. An individual surrounded by a supporting community however, relaxes himself. This type of relaxation translated itself into positive effects on the physiology of the body, which in turn leads to disease prevention and, sometimes, disease remission. 


In case you find yourself thinking that you’re not lacking any relaxation, so you can hold off on your sports class this week and give yourself some slack when it comes to diet, then I’ve unfortunately relayed the wrong message. A healthy lifestyle is essential to do as little harm to your body as possible. But do realize that the wellbeing of your mind, and specifically spending enough time in relaxation, has an unparalleled effect on our physical wellbeing! 


Want to read more about the Roseto-effect? Here you find the link to the scientific article that analyses mortality rates of a whopping 50 years life in Roseto. 


Share this blog post

About the author

Alexandra has a Bachelor degree in Psychology and a Master degree in Neuroscience. After having worked in the research field of Healthy Aging at the Free University (VU) in Amsterdam, she left the academic world behind and has lived in Nicaragua ever since. For the past years, she's been working in Nicaragua as a yoga teacher and Thai massage therapist, organizes intensive health retreats and is currently working as an online (health) coach. Apart from welcoming many tourists in her studio, she focuses on contributing to the health consciousness within the local community. She organizes health weeks, and gives free yoga classes, therapeutic massages and health consults to local Nicaraguan people who cannot otherwise afford it.

Sign up for a Healthy Perspective

Curious about more scientific discoveries on the influence of our psychological state of mind on physical health?

Sign up via the button above to receive these monthly blog posts directly to your inbox

door Alexandra Weeber 12 november 2020
Every self-help book will tell you the same: visualize and you'll manifest! Is this just a popular myth or is it backed up by science?
door Alexandra Weeber 26 oktober 2020
When more than half the population suffers from chronic conditions, can our 'normal' still be seen as healthy? Maybe it's time to radically change course.
door Alexandra Weeber 11 oktober 2020
Someone who got heavily bullied might walk with his shoulders hunched forwards, whereas the CEO who bursts with self-confidence will sit across from you with his knees wide open (guess what, it is believed that confident men love to show their ‘business’). We can read so much information from someones body posture, how is that exactly possible? Decennia ago science already showed that a closed body posture negatively influences your mood in that moment in time, whereas an open posture has a positive influence on mood. But does this work the other way around as well? Could positive / negative experiences not only get stored in our mind, but also in our physical body? 'Your issues are stored in your tissues' is a popular saying in the field of alternative medicine. The idea that your body, specifically your connective tissue (fascia), can store emotional memories is a well-accepted principle within disciplines such as Yin Yoga, Traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), etc. As a Thai massage therapist myself, I believe this just as easily as the idea that we’re breathing oxygen. On a daily basis I see emotions being liberated when the physical body is being opened. Even better; you can often predict which emotions release with the opening of which body parts. When it comes to centuries old medicinal traditions (Ayurveda, TCM), this all makes perfect sense. These traditions are based on the idea that there are energy lines running through the body (known as meridians, nadis, SEN, etc) where our vital life energy runs through. These energy lines correspond to organs and emotions. When you experience physical, emotional or energetic trauma, these energy lines can get blocked and your physical body falls ill. However, when you unblock these energy lines by physically opening the body, the life energy can flow freely again (the principle behind different healing practices). Such a stored trauma, be it physical or emotional, which previously prevented the body from keeping itself balanced, can now be released and the body can heal itself again. Like the Nobel Prize winner Albert Szent once said: “In every culture and in every medical tradition before ours, healing was reached through the movement of energy”. For some people this might sound logical and easily acceptable. After all, some therapies that are based on this principle (think of acupuncture) are now being widely applied and combined with conventional medicine. However, in case this is a far-from-your-bed-show, don’t leave me just yet. Modern science seems to find quite some evidence lately that confirm these traditional theories. Let’s zoom in on Traditional Chinese Medicine. A popular treatment in TCM is called acupuncture; tiny needles are placed in the skin on specific acupoints that are located on the meridians; the energy lines that TCM is based upon. Apart from the many studies that have proven the efficacy of acupuncture as treatment for chronic pain conditions (which the skeptics among us might attribute to the placebo effect), research has also confirmed the mere physical presence of these energy lines and acupoints. It turns out that light is spreading about 20% better through lines in the body corresponding with the meridians than in reference lines. Also, a high energy metabolism takes place on the location of the meridians, which is even higher on the exact location of the acupoints. Another study showed that these acupoints can be stimulated by the resonance of music. Furthermore, in agreement with TCM theories, there seems to be a ‘cross-over’ effect: stimulating one meridian affects other meridians. In short, there is evidence that the energy lines that TCM is based on can be traced in the physical body. So where exactly are they located in our body? When it comes to location of the meridians and acupoints, ultrasounds and postmortem research show that these are primarily located in our connective tissues, or more specifically in the fascia, both between and within the muscles. Interestingly, this is exactly the tissue that the recently developed but quickly rising in popularity discipline Yin Yoga is focussed on; opening of our connective tissue so that our life energy can flow free again. Sounds vague? You can easily experience this for yourself. Give it a try at home: take a Yin yoga position that is meant to open your hips, while trying to relax your muscles as much as possible. This way, the stress of the stretch won’t affect your muscles so much, but rather work on the connective tissue. This tissue needs about 30-60 seconds to slowly start to open up. To facilitate this, don’t push yourself to the limit into the pose, but rather look for a 90% stretch. Stay here for about 3 minutes without making any movement. You’ll see that this exercise might not only be uncomfortable physically, but also mentally. Many people might experience, especially the first times, feelings of frustration. Is this a coincidence? Not according to TCM; the meridians of the liver and gal bladder run through the hip area, and these meridians are associated with feeling of resp. anger and frustration whenever they are blocked (or kindness when energy is flowing freely!). In need again of a scientific reality check? While science leaves plenty of room for future studies researching the relationship between energy lines and the emotions that they’re associated with in traditional Asian philosophies, in 2017 a study has been done that tried to quantify this relationship. Results showed a clear association: the liver was linked to anger, the heart to happiness, the lungs to sadness, etc.. To conclude, science has clearly shown evidence for the validity of century old ideas that the body contains energy lines that are connected to organs and emotions. This supports the idea that emotional trauma will affect the physical body. However, modern medicine often tends to ignore this idea completely. How often has your GP advised you to, in addition to your regular treatment for physical problems, process your emotional traumas (big or small, we all have them..)? Many will never have experienced this. And when we’re being completely honest with ourselves, maybe we wouldn’t have received it very well either? Does that mean that modern medicine is a step back compared to traditional medicine? On the contrary!!! The advances in both knowledge and technology over the past centuries are literally life savers. Imagine getting to the hospital with a gaping abdominal wound and the doctor recommends balancing your energy lines through acupuncture or massage so that the body can heal itself better… I’d prefer a modern medicine doctor in an emergency room! Nevertheless, traditional and modern medicine do not always have to be mutually exclusive. Think about chronic diseases that did not develop from an acute injury, but developed over a long period of time. All that time prior to the full expression of symptoms and a doctors diagnosis, the body hadn’t been able to balance itself, leaving room for a disease to brood under the surface. In these cases, a so-called ‘holistic’ treatment, where not only physical but also emotional and energetic causes and solutions are being examined, could provide many benefits. Both as a cure as well as to prevent disease. In need of some emotional release and curious to Yin yoga? Try it out with this short video!
Share by: